When it comes to iconic street food in New York City, nothing beats the humble hot dog. From street carts to gourmet stands, NYC’s hot dog culture is as diverse as the city itself. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a lifelong New Yorker, exploring the best hot dog spots in the city is a delicious way to experience its vibrant food scene. Ready to savor NYC’s best dogs? Let’s dive into this ultimate guide.
A Brief History of Hot Dogs in NYC The hot dog’s journey to New York City began in the 19th century with German immigrants who brought sausages and bread rolls. In 1871, Charles Feltman, a German immigrant, opened the first hot dog stand in Coney Island, revolutionizing fast food culture. Later, Nathan Handwerker’s Nathan’s Famous popularized the hot dog, making it a quintessential NYC treat. Today, hot dogs are a beloved staple, found everywhere from corner carts to upscale eateries.
What to Visit for Hot Dog Lovers
- Nathan’s Famous in Coney Island: A pilgrimage site for hot dog aficionados, Nathan’s is where it all began. Don’t miss the annual Hot Dog Eating Contest every July 4th.
- Gray’s Papaya: Known for its “recession special,” this Manhattan staple offers affordable and delicious hot dogs paired with tropical drinks.
- Crif Dogs: A quirky spot in the East Village offering creative twists like bacon-wrapped hot dogs and unique toppings.
- Katz’s Delicatessen: While famous for pastrami, Katz’s serves up a solid hot dog that pairs perfectly with its legendary pickles.
Visiting Hours and Tips
- Nathan’s Famous: Open daily, typically from 10:00 AM to midnight.
- Gray’s Papaya: Open 24/7, making it a favorite for late-night cravings.
- Crif Dogs: Usually open from late afternoon to midnight, perfect for dinner or evening snacks.
- Check specific websites or Google listings for updated hours, especially on holidays.
Entry and Pricing
- Nathan’s Famous: Hot dogs start at around $5.
- Gray’s Papaya: Two hot dogs and a drink for about $7.
- Crif Dogs: Gourmet hot dogs range from $7-$10.
- Street Carts: Classic hot dogs average $2-$4, offering a quick and affordable option.
Getting There and Locations
- Nathan’s Famous: Located at 1310 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, easily accessible via the D, F, N, or Q subway lines to Coney Island-Stillwell Avenue.
- Gray’s Papaya: Multiple locations; the flagship store is at 2090 Broadway near 72nd Street.
- Crif Dogs: Found at 113 St. Marks Place, East Village.
- Street carts: Scattered throughout the city, with a high concentration in Midtown and near tourist attractions like Central Park and Times Square.
Where to Eat Hot Dogs in NYC If you’re looking for a mix of traditional and modern takes on hot dogs, here are some recommendations:
- Papaya King: Another classic spot with tropical drink pairings.
- Shake Shack: Known for its burgers, but its hot dogs are equally satisfying.
- Chelsea Market: Explore artisan hot dog vendors among other culinary delights.
Insider Tips
- Always carry cash, especially when buying from street vendors.
- Customize your toppings! New York’s hot dog scene offers everything from classic mustard and sauerkraut to innovative options like avocado and kimchi.
- Visit during lunch hours for the freshest servings, especially at busy spots.
Additional Visitor Information (Hot dogs in New York)
- Hot Dog Etiquette: Grab a napkin and enjoy on the go – it’s part of the NYC experience.
- Seasonal Events: Attend the Coney Island Hot Dog Eating Contest for a uniquely New York experience.
- Dietary Options: Many vendors now offer vegetarian or gluten-free hot dog alternatives.
